Ah yes, as predicted, she thinks he's a lunatic. An overwhelming temptation washes over Rory at that moment: go ahead, pass it off as a joke, or a dare from a friend. Do anything but keep pushing toward the truth. He wants to. He can't.

"Pippa. Look at your hand." His voice, though still gentle, has turned firm and persuasive. "Could I have done that if what I've told you wasn't true?"

His thoughts are equal parts please believe me and please don't fear me. He wonders how much is showing through his eyes.